Uncategorized

Master the NCAT Scott Schedule Template

By Glen Sim

A Scott Schedule helps organise disputed building items, the parties’ positions and the evidence supporting them. This guide focuses on preparing clear entries and checking them before exchange. For professional assistance, see Awesim’s Scott Schedule service.

Use the schedule to make each issue clear

Give each issue a stable reference and location. Explain what is alleged, what work was required and where the supporting evidence can be found. A reader should be able to move from the entry to the relevant report, photograph and cost assessment.

The schedule organises the dispute; it does not establish a defect, liability or a particular settlement outcome by itself. Those questions depend on the evidence, applicable law and decision in the matter.

Obtain the correct form

Download the relevant document from NCAT’s official forms page. The defective workmanship form includes the parties’ comments and loss estimates and a field reserved for the Member. Our column guide explains the fields.

The respondent’s estimate is required by that form even when liability is denied. Keep the liability response distinct from the estimate and do not complete the Member’s comments.

Read the directions for your case

Confirm the required format, who prepares and responds, and the exchange and filing dates. Ask about an unclear direction before the deadline. Schedule 7 of the UCPR is an expert code for relevant court proceedings, not a Scott Schedule template.

Expert evidence requirements and the directions to prepare a schedule are related but distinct. Give the expert the orders and relevant reporting requirements when commissioning the work.

Develop an entry from observations to evidence

The examples below are fictional preparation prompts, not completed findings, repair specifications or official form entries.

Observed concernInformation to establish before finalising the claim
Damp staining to a hallway wall beside a shower.Identify the location, dates, photographs and any testing. Investigate the source and pathway before attributing the staining to a failed membrane. Reference the supported opinion, proposed repairs and cost evidence.
Peeling paint at identified locations in a living room.Record the affected area and condition. Assess possible moisture, substrate and application factors before selecting a cause or repair scope. Cite the relevant documents and technical findings.

An entry should distinguish what was seen from what is inferred. Do not insert an Australian Standard edition, cause, contractor quote or price simply because it appears in an example.

Use real report and photograph references from your matter. Where further investigation is needed, state that limit rather than inventing a concluded finding.

Match technical and cost assistance to the issues

A building expert may investigate the alleged defect, cause and rectification. Cost evidence may involve a suitably experienced consultant, quantity surveyor or contractor, depending on the question and required expertise.

The job title alone does not determine the weight of the evidence. Explain the scope, quantities, rates, exclusions and assumptions behind the estimate. Make clear whether GST is included and avoid double-counting shared access or setup work.

A separate quantity surveyor is not automatically required simply because a property is strata or the other party has an expert. Assess the issues, expertise and directions with the legal representative handling the matter.

Check consistency before exchange

  • Use specific locations and stable item numbers.
  • Keep observations, causes, repair scope and price distinct.
  • Check each reference against the actual attachment.
  • Retain qualifications when summarising an expert opinion.
  • Explain cost assumptions and shared allowances.
  • Record changes between versions and follow the exchange directions.

Do not omit an item solely because it appears cosmetic. Whether it belongs in the claim depends on the facts, legal basis and scope of the proceeding. Obtain advice where necessary.

Compare the actual areas of agreement

Work through defect, scope and cost separately. The parties may agree that a defect exists while disagreeing about its cause, repair method or price. Recording that distinction helps focus the remaining investigation and discussion.

A schedule can support negotiation and hearing preparation, but it cannot promise a percentage reduction in hearing time or a particular likelihood of settlement.

Request assistance with the work you need

Specify whether the task is an applicant’s schedule, respondent’s reply, response to another expert or joint document. Supply the directions, current version, reports, contract documents, photographs and deadline.

Awesim can assess the investigation and reporting scope for NSW building matters. Confirm availability and the deliverables in a written proposal.

Frequently asked questions

Can a schedule be prepared before proceedings?

It can help organise issues for advice or negotiation. If proceedings follow, check the required form and directions before filing it.

Is the same format required in court?

Check the relevant court’s practice requirements and case orders. Do not assume an NCAT form is automatically the directed court format.

What if the other party does not respond?

Keep the exchange record and raise the missed requirement with the Tribunal as appropriate. The Tribunal decides any further directions or consequences; an unanswered item is not an automatic win.

Review the schedule against the evidence

Before exchange, check that the entries reflect the reports and that each uncertainty is clear. Contact Awesim to discuss the technical preparation or review required.

author avatar
Glen Sim Managing Director
Glen Sim is the Founder and Director of Awesim Building Consultants. He is a qualified carpenter, licensed builder and building expert witness with more than 35 years of construction experience. Based in New South Wales, he provides building consultancy, expert witness reports, Scott Schedules and building defect inspections across Australia, including support for NCAT building disputes in NSW.

Share the Post:

Scroll to Top