Uncategorized

Your Guide to a Construction Expert Witness

By Glen Sim

A construction expert witness provides independent technical opinions on issues in a building dispute. The work may include investigation, document review, assessment of another report, rectification advice or valuation questions within the expert’s field.

Define the technical question

Start with the issue that needs an opinion: whether particular work is defective, what caused a condition, what investigation is needed, what repairs are appropriate or how a defined scope should be costed. These questions may require different expertise.

A useful report explains the evidence and reasoning, including alternative explanations and limits. It distinguishes a technical assessment from legal responsibility and the decision about the outcome of the claim.

Agree the work included

  • Review the relevant contract, drawings, specifications and records.
  • Inspect and test where needed and authorised.
  • Record observations and assess the disputed technical issues.
  • Explain any repair scope and cost opinion requested.
  • Prepare or respond to reports and schedules within the agreed brief.
  • Attend expert conferences or give evidence where required and separately arranged.

For NCAT, provide the orders and Procedural Direction 3 with the brief. For court proceedings, check the applicable code, rules and practice requirements. Our guide to the expert’s duty explains the distinction.

Do not assume that a builder’s quote or earlier inspection is either sufficient or automatically unusable. Identify what it proves, who prepared it and what further technical explanation the matter requires.

Follow directions for expert discussions

If experts are directed to confer, confirm the issues, documents, attendance arrangements and required joint output. A joint report should identify agreement, disagreement and the reasons, while each expert maintains their independent judgment.

Look for a clear path from evidence to opinion

Discuss the report’s scope, the author’s relevant expertise, instructions, documents, investigation, observations, assumptions and reasons. Confirm the acknowledgements and disclosures required for the proceeding.

For a reported leak, for example, an inspection should distinguish visible moisture damage from the evidence for its source. The recommended repairs should follow from the supported cause and investigation, rather than a generic repair package.

Coordinate the report and schedule

A Scott Schedule summarises the parties’ positions by item; the report explains the technical reasoning. Keep item references, repair scopes, cost assumptions and qualifications consistent across the documents.

Confirm timing before engagement

Provide the next deadline and allow for document review, site access, testing and report preparation. Ask the expert to identify any missing information or specialist work that could affect delivery.

Later expert conferences, responses and hearing attendance have their own timing and availability requirements. Confirm these separately rather than assuming the initial report engagement covers every stage.

Compare the proposed scope and fee

Request a written proposal identifying the deliverables, exclusions, fees, GST, travel and specialist costs. Awesim’s published fee guide is indicative; confirm the total and included work for your matter.

Check whether the fee covers inspection, testing, a new report, a response, a Scott Schedule, revisions, conferences or attendance. Agree how additional work will be authorised.

Choose relevant expertise

Ask who will undertake the investigation, form the opinions, sign the report and attend if required. Discuss their experience with the particular building elements and questions. Seek specialist input where an issue is outside that person’s expertise.

A previous relationship with a party should be disclosed and considered under the applicable requirements. The expert’s conclusions must remain independent of the result the client hopes to achieve.

Provide the available evidence early

Send the orders, existing reports, contract, plans, photographs and correspondence relevant to the issues. Explain any repairs already undertaken, access restrictions and proposed work that may change the condition being investigated.

Frequently asked questions

Does every building dispute require the same report?

No. The disputed questions, available evidence and directions determine the work needed. Confirm the brief before commissioning an investigation.

Can a contractor’s quote help?

It may provide evidence about a defined repair scope and price. Check whether separate reasoning on defects, causation or the appropriate scope is also needed.

Is a jointly prepared report the same as a single expert report?

They are different arrangements. Confirm the appointment, instructions and joint-report process under the directions for the matter.

Can an expert guarantee success?

No. The expert provides technical assistance within their expertise; the court or Tribunal determines the contested claim.

Discuss your matter with Awesim

Awesim brings more than 35 years of construction experience and more than 15 years of litigation support to NSW building matters. Read about our expert witness reports or contact us with the property location, issue list and deadline.

author avatar
Glen Sim Managing Director
Glen Sim is the Founder and Director of Awesim Building Consultants. He is a qualified carpenter, licensed builder and building expert witness with more than 35 years of construction experience. Based in New South Wales, he provides building consultancy, expert witness reports, Scott Schedules and building defect inspections across Australia, including support for NCAT building disputes in NSW.

Share the Post:

Scroll to Top